Green’s Dictionary of Slang

1. (also faggoty-assed) effeminate, homosexual [+ -assed sfx (2)].

1928		C. McKay Home to Harlem 36: And there is two things in Harlem I don’t understand / It is a bulldycking woman and a faggotty man.
1931		N. Van Patten ‘Vocab. of the Amer. Negro’ in AS VII:1 28: faggoty. M. adj. Perverted.
1950		Goldin et al. DAUL 67/1: Faggoty. Of, like, or pertaining to fags, i. e., effeminate.
1959		M. Richler Apprenticeship of Duddy Kravitz (1964) 209: They have their special little faggoty nightclubs in every city.
1962		P. Crump Burn, Killer, Burn! 292: That big, muscle-bound, faggoty-assed bastard.
1967		W. Manus Mott the Hoople 206: I extended a limp faggotty hand and said Enchanté.
1974		C. Loken Come Monday Morning 59: That rich yellowbelly Martin an’ the faggoty Jew what’s his name.
1996		P. Howard The Joy (2015) [ebook] What with their faggoty voices and the earrings in their right ears, there was no need to ask questions.
2000		T. Blacker Kill Your Darlings 57: He lifted his hands in a faggoty two-fingered clawing motion.
2000		G. Pelecanos Shame the Devil 48: Bobby, the faggoty young chef who called himself an artist.
2005		P. Howard Curious Incident of the Dog in the Nightdress 217: Get that faggoty one [i.e. jersey] off you.

2. cowardly, useless, second-rate.

1964		J. Baldwin Blues for Mister Charlie 42: Every one of them’s got some piss-assed faggoty white boy on a string somewhere.
1975		E. Torres Carlito’s Way 116: This faggoty D.A. [...] kept calling me a murderer.

3. of an inanimate object, insignificant.

2006

P. Brauner Slipping into Darkness 29: ‘Seven motherfuckin’ years I did for selling two little faggoty bottles of crack’.