Green’s Dictionary of Slang

dagger n.1

the penis.

[[UK]J. Haywood A Mery Play n.p.: An homycyde thou art I know well inoughe / For my selfe knew where thou sloughe / A wenche with thy dagger in a couche].
[UK]Middleton & Rowley Old Law (1656) III i: cook.: I must a wooing. but.: Ile buy me a new dagger, and overtake you. bay.: So we must all, for he that goes a wooing to a Widdow without a Weapon will never get her.
[UK]Le Strange Merry Passages and Jeasts No. 560 150: For sure the Dagger’s in the Sheath, when the Children are gotten.
[UK]M. Stevenson Wits Paraphras’d 97: For notwithstanding all your swaggar, / To me all’s standing but your Daggar.
[Scot]Order of the Beggar's Benison and Merryland (1892) 21: Dinner Sentiments [...] The Female Cave; the open space for Cupid’s Rudder; the fine Sheath for the bold Dagger.
[UK]Banquet of Wit 102: Sentiments and Toasts [...] Adam’s dagger.
[UK] ‘Do As Father & Mother Do’ Cockchafer 44: Says Dick, ‘it’s true, a dagger long, / I have got, my sweet delight.
‘Cat’ [broadsheet ballad] He push’d in his dagger so stiff and so stout.
[UK]Farmer & Henley Sl. and Its Analogues.
[UK]‘Voluptuous Night’ in Cabinet of Venus 47: How delicious to feel their soft compressive rubbing against my dagger.
[UK]A. Cairene Sixfold Sensuality 8: He immediately pushed his dagger into her sheath.
[US] ‘Kansas City Kitty’ [comic strip] in B. Adelman Tijuana Bibles (1997) 54: He took my hand and put it on the front of his pants and I felt that hard dagger.
[US]Frank Zappa ‘Bwana Dik’ 🎵 My dick is a dagger / I’ll force it to fit.
[UK]J. Mowry Six Out Seven (1994) 135: Slowly, cautiously, he took hold of himself with one hand, far back from the tip of his unsheathed dagger.

In phrases

throw one’s dagger (v.)

(US campus) to have sexual intercourse.

[US]P. Munro Sl. U. 192: Did you throw your dagger last night?