Green’s Dictionary of Slang

cribbage-faced adj.

[the supposed resemblance of such scars to the small holes found in a cribbage board]

a face marked with smallpox scars.

[UK]Grose Classical Dict. of the Vulgar Tongue.
[UK]Lex. Balatronicum.
[US]R. Waln Hermit in America on Visit to Phila. 2nd series 28: She was [...] Cribbage-facedBeetle-headedBottle-headedBuffle-headed — and Chuckle-headed!!!
[UK]Egan Grose’s Classical Dict. of the Vulgar Tongue.
[UK]Hotten Dict. of Modern Sl. etc. (2nd edn).
[UK]Hotten Sl. Dict.
[UK]Sl. Dict.
[Aus]Sydney Sl. Dict. (2 edn) 3: Cribbage-faced - Pock-marked.
[Aus]Crowe Aus. Sl. Dict. 20: Cribbage-faced, marked with small-pox.